I’m using Previously I used DxO Optics pro to adjust and correct some of my images. But because of their stupid licensing system I’ve been forced to use other solutions lately.
And my conclusion is that you probably don’t need DxO.
I’m using several professional software packages. Adobe Lightroom, Photoshop, Final Cut Pro, iStopMotion Pro. Elgato Turbo HD, Apple Keynote etc. Pretty expensive and professional software.
I’m working on several different computers. But my main workstations are:
1. My MacBook Pro (on the road)
2. My 24″ iMac (at home)
3. My MacMini (for time consuming batch jobs)
I would guess that laptop + desktop machine is pretty usual. But because I’m working on huge amounts of large files I also use my MacMini from time to time. Simply because that’s the computer that is running 24/7.
And all my professional software is installed on all these computers. I use the same license key on all of them because I never use the computers at the same time.
But this won’t work for DxO. When you buy their 299 Euro Elite license you’re only allowed to install the software on two computers.
I’ve run into trouble several times because of this.
Here is one scenario: installed on iMac and MacBook pro. Then my MacBook pro died. I get a new machine and get a message that I’m not allowed to install on an extra computer. My two installs are already used.
The result is that I have to send an email to DxO and wait for an answer and then after explaining the problem I’m granted access to another install.
Currently I’m running DxO on my laptop and my iMac. A couple of days ago I returned from a holliday and wanted to start a huge batch job of DxO processing on my MacMini. When I tried to install it I got the usual message: not allowed.
I email DxO and explain the problem. I’ve paid for the license. I don’t want to run it on several computers at the same time, but I want to be able to run it on the computer in my house that is running 24/7 so it can do the processing while I’m sleeping. Yes, I could set my iMac to run all night, but that wouldn’t be very environmentally friendly, and it is the MacMini that is placed in our home in a way where it can run all night without disturbing us with noise etc.
In total I had to wait for more than a week for this answer from DxO.:
Thank you. The license agreement limits installation and activation to two systems at the same time. If you do need a third activation, that will require the purchase of an additional license.
DxO Support Team
Well, I don’t have to buy several licenses of Lightroom, Photoshop, Keynote, iStopMotion and all the other packages I use just because I want to install them on the three computers I use.
Fortunately the latest version of Lightroom have included lens correction. And my quick tests show that for me, I really don’t need DxO anymore. This is not a scientific test and I really, really hope that the DxO correction is way better than the Lightroom correction. Or, at least 299 Euro worth of pure quality… But for me, the benefits of using Lightroom exceeds the extra hassle and probably slightly better quality of DxO:
– Lightroom doesn’t have that stupid licensing system
– Lightroom is much faster
– Keeping all my work inside of Lightroom gives a much simpler workflow
– For me, the quality is good enough
Here is my quick test. Using a fisheye image shot with my Canon 5D Mark II and my Canon 15mm f2.8 fisheye:
Comparison from a corner of the image. No defish but all lens corrections (click the image for full size):
2 thoughts on “DxO and their completely ridiculous licensing”
We’re not closing ourselves in in a managed solution like Lightroom or Aperture. Though when Adobe announced Adobe RAW Converter (plugin) with lens the current lens correction tools, we dropped DXO like a stone.
– DXO is cumbersome to use
– Terrible UI
– Really slow previews
– Really slow processing
– Hard to integrate in the workflow
And the new Adobe lens correction tools are pretty good and it fits nicely in the workflow.
More importantly, corrections are stored losslessly in the .xmp files. Only to be processed when we need to, together with the color changes.
According to the Lightroom EULA you can only install the Lightroom application on one computer. The only difference is that DxO enforces its policy, while Lightroom let you violate the licence terms.